Peer Review Policy
Purpose and scope
The Journal of Leaderology and Applied Leadership (JALA) is the official journal of the National Leaderology Association (NLA). This policy describes how JALA evaluates manuscripts submitted for publication: the review model, how reviewers are chosen, the timelines reviewers and authors can expect, how conflicts of interest are managed, how decisions are made, and how authors may appeal. It applies to the four JALA article types: Empirical Study, Original Theory, Practical Application, and Commentary. The NLA board serves as JALA’s editorial board and governs the journal, and it may review and override any editorial decision.
Board Insights, the Association’s repository of members’ working papers, are posted by the editor and do not pass through peer review.
Review model
JALA uses double-blind peer review. Reviewers do not learn the identity of the authors, and authors do not learn the identity of the reviewers. Before a manuscript reaches reviewers, the editorial office prepares a blinded copy. That copy removes the title-page block with author names, affiliations, email addresses, ORCID iDs, and correspondence details. It also removes acknowledgments, funding statements, and author notes that identify the author, strips names from running headers, footers, and document properties, and replaces self-identifying citations with “Author (Year)” in the text and the reference list. The title, abstract, keywords, body, tables, figures, and anonymized reference list remain intact. The editorial office adds continuous line numbers so reviewers can tie each comment to an exact location. When a figure or image must be removed because it identifies the author, the editorial office records the removal, and the author may restore it in the revised or final manuscript.
Each manuscript that passes the initial screen is sent to at least two reviewers. Reviewers receive the blinded manuscript and the JALA reviewer guidelines as email attachments. They do not receive shared links to journal files, the original manuscript, the author’s identity, or the name of the other reviewer. When reviewer comments go back to the author, the reviewers are labeled Reviewer A and Reviewer B.
Initial editorial screening
Every submission is screened before reviewers are chosen, and the screen covers scope and format. A manuscript is in scope when its focus is leadership or followership, studied as a science or applied as a practice. Management-only submissions are declined at this stage. The format check confirms a Microsoft Word file, APA 7th edition style, Times New Roman 12-point type, double spacing, one-inch margins, a title page, an abstract of 150 to 250 words, and a reference list. Empirical studies are limited to 20 pages, and Practical Application articles and Commentaries run 1,500 to 3,000 words, with references excluded in both cases. Original Theory articles have no fixed length limit; their length should suit the theory being developed, and the editor may ask an author to shorten one.
A manuscript outside scope is declined without review, and the author is told the reason. A manuscript with format problems is placed on hold and returned to the author with a list of the items to correct, and the corrected file re-enters screening. Every submission passes through automated similarity screening before it goes to reviewers, and the editor examines any significant overlap with published work, including the authors’ own, before the manuscript moves forward.
Reviewer selection
Reviewers are drawn from JALA’s active reviewer pool, which the editorial office maintains. Pool members hold a doctoral degree or have a record of published work in leadership, and the editor invites them to join. When a manuscript needs expertise the pool lacks, the editor may invite a qualified reviewer from outside it.
Assignment follows a rotation rule that spreads the workload and keeps any one reviewer from shaping a disproportionate share of the journal’s content. Among active reviewers, the editorial office first excludes anyone named as an author or co-author, anyone who shares the primary author’s institution, and anyone with a known conflict on that manuscript. From those who remain, it assigns the two whose last JALA assignment is oldest. A reviewer who has never been assigned goes first, and ties are broken at random. When several manuscripts arrive together, no reviewer receives a second manuscript from that group until every eligible reviewer has one. If fewer than two eligible reviewers remain, the editor names a substitute.
Timelines
Reviewers are asked to return their reviews within 45 days of the date the manuscript is sent. Because JALA’s reviewers are volunteers and some manuscripts take longer than others, the editorial office sends a gentle check-in on day 45 to any reviewer whose review is still outstanding, asking where things stand. If the review remains outstanding on day 60, a replacement reviewer is assigned automatically and receives a fresh package. If a reviewer declines an invitation, the next eligible reviewer is assigned the same day.
Authors receive the editor’s decision once both reviews are in and the editor has considered them. JALA accepts submissions at any time. At its current volume, JALA sets no fixed turnaround target, and an issue is published once about five accepted manuscripts of sufficient quality are ready. Authors are asked to return revisions within 60 days of the decision letter, and a revision that arrives later may be treated as a new submission.
What reviewers evaluate
Reviewers assess each manuscript against the JALA reviewer guidelines, which cover ten areas: relevance and significance, originality, theory and current literature, clarity and organization, methods and rigor, data and analysis, discussion and conclusions, ethics, references, and suitability for JALA. The methodological questions apply according to article type. An empirical study is held to standards of design, rigor, and replicability. A practical article is judged on whether its recommendations rest on valid existing research, and a theoretical article on whether the theory is appropriate and well explained.
Each review has two parts: notes for the author, citing line numbers, and comments for the editor that are not forwarded to the author. Each reviewer closes with one of three recommendations: Publish as is, Edits needed, or Reject. A Reject recommendation must state its reason.
Editorial decisions
JALA’s decisions follow the reviewers’ recommendations. The Editor in Chief signs off on each decision for any manuscript in which they have no personal stake, and the NLA board may review and override any decision. The journal issues one of four decisions: Accept, Minor revision, Major revision, or Reject.
When both reviewers recommend Publish as is, the manuscript is accepted. When both recommend Edits needed, the author revises the manuscript to address their notes. A minor revision addresses clarity, citations, local structure, or missing limitations, and a major revision addresses methods, theory, data, ethics, or the central argument. When both recommend Reject, the manuscript is declined, and the author may appeal to the NLA board under the process below. When the two recommendations conflict, the editorial office’s automated workflow assigns a third reviewer from the pool under the same selection rules. The Editor in Chief then decides with all three reports in hand, including the comments to the editor, before any letter goes to the author.
The author receives a single document that opens with a consolidated summary of revision priorities, followed by each reviewer’s notes in full, along with the blinded copy so the cited line numbers match. Comments marked for the editor are not shared with the author. A decision rests on at least two completed reviews.
Revisions
Authors submit revised manuscripts by reply to the decision letter. When the revision makes the changes the reviewers requested, the manuscript is accepted. A revision that returns to the reviewers is blinded again and receives a new line-numbered file. A major revision returns to the reviewers who requested the changes, and they judge whether the changes were made. A minor revision is checked against the reviewers’ notes by the editorial office’s automated workflow, and the Editor in Chief verifies the changes before the manuscript is accepted. Each revision comes with a brief response to reviewers that lists every change and where it appears.
Production and publication
Once a manuscript is accepted, the editorial office prepares the production package: the article set in the journal template, the PDF, and the web version, with every table and figure carried over and checked against the author’s file. The Editor in Chief approves the final package, and the article is published in the next available issue.
Conflicts of interest
JALA asks every party to the review process to disclose interests that could reasonably appear to influence judgment.
Authors declare any potential conflict of interest on the submission form and in the cover letter, along with funding sources and ethical approvals.
Reviewers are excluded from any manuscript they authored or co-authored and from any manuscript whose primary author shares their institution. At invitation, reviewers declare any other conflict, such as a recent collaboration, a competing interest, or a personal relationship with the likely author, and decline the review when one exists.
Editors, reviewers, and Association officers sometimes submit their own work to JALA. When a manuscript is authored by a member of the editorial team, a reviewer, or an officer or board member of the National Leaderology Association, that person takes no part in handling it, is excluded from reviewer assignment for it, and has no access to its review records or its decision. The manuscript goes through the same double-blind review as any other submission.
A manuscript authored by the Editor in Chief is handled by a senior member of the editorial team or reviewer pool, who manages its review and makes the decision. The Editor in Chief has no role in that review or decision. While serving, the current Editor in Chief does not submit manuscripts to the journal; any work they share appears in Board Insights.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers may not share, cite, or use a manuscript or its content, or discuss it with others, before publication. Reviewer identities, comments to the editor, and the internal files that link reviewers to manuscripts stay with the editorial office. Reviewers may not upload a manuscript, or any part of it, to an AI service, because doing so breaches its confidentiality. Each reviewer is responsible for every judgment in their review.
JALA uses AI-assisted tools to run much of its editorial office. These tools handle intake, logging, manuscript blinding, similarity screening, reviewer assignment and correspondence, checks of minor revisions, and preparation of the production package. Every manuscript is evaluated by reviewers from the JALA reviewer pool, and author letters are approved by the editor before they are sent.
Ethics concerns raised in review
When a reviewer raises plagiarism, an undisclosed conflict of interest, or missing ethical approval for research involving human participants, the editorial office pauses the manuscript and refers it to the editor. The editor looks into the concern before any decision is sent. JALA’s Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement governs the handling of suspected misconduct, and corrections and retractions follow COPE guidance.
Appeals
An author who believes a decision rested on a factual error, a misreading of the manuscript, a procedural failure, or an undisclosed conflict of interest may appeal. Appeals that only restate disagreement with the reviewers’ judgment are not heard.
- The author sends a written appeal to the editorial office at info@NLAInfo.org within 30 days of the decision, stating the grounds and responding point by point to the reviewer comments at issue.
- The editorial office acknowledges the appeal and logs it.
- The NLA board reviews the appeal, the manuscript, and the review record, and decides the appeal. Any board member who took part in the original decision steps aside.
- The board may seek a further review from a reviewer who took no part in the original evaluation.
- The author receives a written decision, normally within 30 days of the appeal. The appeal decision is final, and each manuscript may be appealed once.
Complaints about the journal’s process that are not appeals of a decision follow the complaints procedure in the Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement.
Policy review
The Editor in Chief reviews this policy each year. Last updated: November 14, 2026.