Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
The Journal of Leaderology and Applied Leadership (JALA)
Published by the National Leaderology Association | Online ISSN 3065-7253
Purpose and Scope
The Journal of Leaderology and Applied Leadership publishes research, practical application articles, commentaries, and original theory in leaderology, the formal discipline of leadership science, and in the study of followership. Its value to the field depends on the integrity of what it publishes. This statement sets out the ethical duties of everyone involved in that work: the Editor in Chief and editorial board, peer reviewers, authors, and the publisher. It also sets out how JALA handles suspected misconduct, corrections, retractions, complaints, and appeals.
JALA follows the Core Practices and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), including the COPE flowcharts for handling specific cases, and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing issued jointly by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME. Where this statement is silent, the editorial office applies that guidance.
About the Journal
JALA is published by the National Leaderology Association (NLA), a registered 501(c)(6) professional association. The journal is fully open access. All articles are free to read on publication, and authors pay no submission, processing, or publication fees. Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0), which allows anyone to copy and share the work in unaltered form for noncommercial purposes provided the author is credited. Authors retain copyright in their work and grant JALA the right to publish it. Anyone who wants to use the material for commercial purposes must contact the author for permission. The publisher’s revenue comes from the NLA, its members, and donations, and none of it is tied to the acceptance of any manuscript.
Duties of the Editor in Chief and Editorial Board
JALA’s editorial board is the board of the National Leaderology Association. The board oversees the journal and may review or override any editorial decision. The Editor in Chief manages the editorial process day to day and issues decisions on the journal’s behalf, guided by the reviewers’ recommendations. Decisions rest on a manuscript’s importance, originality, clarity, methodological soundness, and relevance to leadership and followership science. The race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, ethnicity, nationality, political views, institutional affiliation, or seniority of an author has no bearing on a decision. Membership in the NLA, or a donation to it, likewise has no bearing.
Editors keep everything about a submitted manuscript confidential. Information about a manuscript is shared only with its corresponding author, its reviewers, members of the editorial board involved in the decision, and the publisher where the publisher’s involvement is required. Unpublished material in a submission is never used in an editor’s own research without the author’s written consent.
An editor who has a competing interest in a manuscript, through a personal, professional, institutional, or financial relationship with an author, recuses from that manuscript and hands it to another member of the editorial board. The Editor in Chief does not submit work to the peer-reviewed journal while in office; any contribution from the Editor in Chief appears in Board Insights, where it is labeled as non-peer-reviewed commentary. When another member of the editorial team submits work to the journal, a senior member of the editorial board with no stake in the manuscript handles it from intake to decision. It goes through the same double-blind review as every other submission, and the submitting editor has no access to the reviewer identities, the reviews, or the decision process. Any published article by an editor carries a note stating that it was handled independently.
Editors screen each submission for scope, format, and completeness before review. A manuscript that falls outside leadership and followership science, including one focused solely on management practice, is declined at this stage with a stated reason. Every decision on a manuscript, including any review of a decision by the board, rests on scholarly merit alone. Commercial, financial, and membership considerations play no part.
JALA’s editorial office uses artificial intelligence tools, supervised by the Editor in Chief, to receive and log submissions, screen them for format and for similarity to existing work, prepare blinded manuscripts, send review packages and reminders, compile reviewer comments for authors, and prepare accepted articles for publication. These tools work only within JALA’s own accounts and files and are bound by the same confidentiality obligations as human staff. Peer reviewers and editors make every judgment about a manuscript’s merit and every publication decision. No AI tool evaluates the quality of a manuscript, writes a review, or decides its outcome, and every letter that conveys a decision is checked and sent by a member of the editorial team.
Duties of Reviewers
Peer review is how JALA decides what deserves publication, and it gives authors guidance that strengthens their work. Reviewers who accept an invitation agree to assess the manuscript against JALA’s reviewer guidelines and to return a review within the requested period, normally 45 days. A reviewer who cannot meet that timeline, or who lacks the expertise the manuscript requires, tells the editorial office promptly so that another reviewer can be assigned.
Reviewers treat every manuscript as a confidential document. They do not share it, discuss it with others, or use its unpublished content for any purpose without the author’s written consent. Reviewers do not upload any part of a manuscript or their review into generative AI tools, since doing so may breach the author’s confidentiality and rights. A reviewer who needs help from a colleague asks the editorial office first and names that colleague.
Reviews are objective and constructive. Personal criticism of an author has no place in a review. Reviewers explain their judgments with clear reasons, cite specific line numbers where possible, and keep any comments meant only for the editor in a separate section. Reviewers point out relevant published work the author has not cited, and they alert the editor to any substantial overlap with other published or submitted work, suspected plagiarism, data concerns, missing ethical approvals, or undisclosed conflicts of interest.
A reviewer who has a competing interest with an author, an author’s institution, or the work itself declines the invitation and says why. JALA does not assign reviewers who are authors or co-authors of the manuscript or who share the primary author’s institution.
Duties of Authors
Authors submit work that is original, that has not been published elsewhere, and that is not under consideration by another journal. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at once is unethical. Previously posted preprints and working papers, such as SSRN postings, may be submitted provided the author discloses them at submission. Authors who reuse material from their own earlier publications identify and cite it.
Authors report their work accurately and with enough detail that others could evaluate or replicate it. Fabricating, falsifying, or selectively reporting data, results, or sources is misconduct. Authors keep their underlying data and materials available for a reasonable period after publication and provide them to the editor on request. Plagiarism in any form, including presenting another person’s ideas, words, or data as one’s own, is misconduct, and every submission is screened for similarity to published and online sources before it goes to review. Self-plagiarism, meaning reuse of an author’s own published text, data, or findings without disclosure and citation, is also misconduct.
Authorship is limited to those who made a substantial contribution to the conception, design, execution, analysis, or interpretation of the work, who took part in drafting or critically revising it, who approved the final version, and who accept accountability for it. Others who contributed are named in the acknowledgments. The corresponding author confirms that all co-authors have approved the submission and agree to its authorship order. Changes to authorship after submission require the written agreement of every author and the approval of the editor.
Authors disclose, in the cover letter and the submission form, every financial or nonfinancial interest that could be seen to influence the work, along with all sources of funding. Research involving human participants or animals complies with recognized ethical standards and carries the approval of the appropriate review board or ethics committee. Authors report the approving body, the approval number, and its dates, and they confirm that informed consent was obtained where required.
Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors, because they cannot take responsibility for the work. Authors who use AI tools to generate, analyze, or substantially edit content describe that use in the methods section or the acknowledgments, naming the tool and the purpose. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy and originality of everything in the manuscript, including any content produced with such tools. Routine spelling and grammar checking does not need to be disclosed.
An author who finds a significant error in their own published work notifies the editor promptly and cooperates in correcting or retracting it.
Duties of the Publisher
The National Leaderology Association supports JALA’s editorial independence and provides the resources the journal needs to operate. The NLA keeps the journal’s content openly available and maintains its archive of back issues on the journal website. JALA deposits every published issue with the Internet Archive for long-term preservation. The NLA works with the Editor in Chief to investigate any suspected misconduct and to publish corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions when they are needed. Its board serves as JALA’s editorial board, as described above.
Peer Review
Research articles, practical application articles, commentaries, and original theory articles undergo double-blind peer review by at least two reviewers after an initial editorial screen. Authors do not learn reviewer identities, and reviewers do not learn author identities. Each reviewer recommends that a manuscript be published as is, revised, or rejected. When the reviewers agree, the editor issues the decision their recommendations support: accept, minor revision, or major revision. A major revision returns to the reviewers who requested the changes, and it is accepted once they confirm that those changes have been made. A minor revision is checked against the reviewers’ notes by the editorial office, and the Editor in Chief verifies the changes before the manuscript is accepted. When the reviewers disagree, a third reviewer from the pool is assigned automatically, and the decision follows the majority recommendation. The Editor in Chief reviews the full record before any rejection is issued. Board Insights, which carries working papers and expert commentary from NLA board members, is not peer reviewed and is labeled as such. The Editor in Chief approves every accepted article before it is published. JALA’s separate Peer Review Policy describes the process in full.
Handling Suspected Misconduct
JALA takes every credible allegation of misconduct seriously, whether it concerns a submitted manuscript or a published article and whether it comes from a reviewer, a reader, an author, or anyone else. Misconduct includes plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data, duplicate or redundant publication, undisclosed conflicts of interest, authorship disputes involving guest or ghost authorship, citation manipulation, manipulation of peer review, and research conducted without required ethical approval. JALA follows the relevant COPE flowchart for each type of concern and applies the following procedure.
- The concern is sent in writing to the editorial office with as much supporting evidence as possible. Anonymous concerns are considered when the evidence can be checked independently.
- The Editor in Chief acknowledges the concern and makes an initial assessment of whether the evidence warrants investigation. If the Editor in Chief has a conflict of interest, another member of the editorial board handles the case.
- While the matter is open, it is kept confidential. The editor gathers the relevant records, such as the manuscript versions, reviews, correspondence, and similarity reports, and may consult a reviewer or subject expert.
- The editor writes to the author or authors, sets out the concern clearly, and gives them a fair opportunity to respond, normally within 30 days.
- If the response resolves the concern, the case is closed and the person who raised it is told the outcome.
- If the response does not resolve it, or if the author does not respond, the editor decides on a proportionate outcome. For a submitted manuscript, outcomes range from a request for revision to rejection. For a published article, outcomes range from a correction to an expression of concern or a retraction.
- Where the concern is serious, such as fabricated data or research without ethical approval, the editor may inform the author’s institution or the body that funded or approved the research and ask it to investigate.
- In cases of proven serious misconduct, the editor may decline further submissions from the author for a stated period.
- The editor records each step and the outcome. The person who raised the concern and the authors are told the result.
Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
JALA corrects the published record whenever an error is found, following the COPE Retraction Guidelines. A correction is published when an error affects part of an article but leaves its main findings sound. A correction is a dated notice linked to the article, and the article itself is updated with the correction shown. An expression of concern is published when there is serious reason to doubt an article’s reliability and an investigation is still under way or cannot reach a conclusion. A retraction is published when the findings are unreliable because of misconduct or major error, when the work was plagiarized or published elsewhere first, or when it was published without required approval. A retracted article stays online, clearly marked as retracted, with a dated notice that states the reason. Articles are removed only in rare legal cases, such as defamation or a serious risk to someone’s privacy or safety, and a notice stating the removal remains in their place.
Complaints and Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe the reviewers or the editor misunderstood the manuscript, made a factual error, or treated it unfairly. Anyone may also complain about the journal’s processes or conduct. JALA handles appeals and complaints through the following procedure.
- The appeal or complaint is sent in writing to the editorial office within 30 days of the decision or event, with a clear explanation of the grounds.
- The editorial office acknowledges receipt.
- The editorial board reviews the full record of the manuscript or matter. Any board member who took part in the original decision or has a conflict of interest steps aside.
- The board may uphold the decision, overturn it, invite a revised submission, or send the manuscript to a new reviewer for a further opinion.
- The person who raised the appeal or complaint receives a written response with reasons.
- The appeal decision is final. A complaint that remains unresolved may be taken to COPE once JALA is a COPE member.
Contact
Concerns about publication ethics, suspected misconduct, corrections, complaints, and appeals can be sent to the JALA editorial office at info@NLAInfo.org.
Editor in Chief: position open; search underway. Interim editorial operations: Dr. David M Robertson, MSL, VL2
Last updated: November 14, 2026